The efficiency curve remains more or less flat over the whole load range. Practical application of highperformance francisturbine. This type of turbine is located in the old lowhead installations less than10 m where they are generally in water chamber, ie without scrollcase. In this video, i explained difference between kaplan and francis turbine. Runner of francis turbine information and library network. The most common types are pelton, francis, kaplan and mixedflow turbines. Its invention allowed efficient power production in lowhead applications which was not possible with francis turbines.
After the inlet the flow makes a right angle turn and enters the runner in an axial direction. In case of francis turbine, these guide vanes are adjustable. For kaplan turbine, the shaft of the turbine is vertical. Pdf design and analysis of a kaplan turbine runner wheel. Kaplan turbine disposition of shaft is only in vertical direction. In a hydro power plant as outlined in the figure, the difference between the level of the upper. Runner of francis turbine the shape of the blades of a francis runner is complex. Difference between pelton, francis and kaplan turbines. Pdf since the clearance between the runner shroud and the hub can. Austrian engineer viktor kaplan 18761934 invented this turbine. A reaction turbine is a type of turbine in which the working fluid comes to the turbine under great pressure and the energy is extracted by the turbine blades from the working fluid generally water unlike pelton turbine in which all the energy of the working fluid is. In the case of the splitterbladefitted runner, since. Francis turbine is radial flow turbine but in case of modern francis turbine water enters radially and leaves the turbine axially which is called as mixed flow turbine. It is the casing in which guides the water and control the water passage.
Is also an axial flow reaction turbine in which water flows in the direction parallel to the axis of rotation of the runner. Kaplan turbine is more compact in crosssection and has higher rotational speed to that of francis hydro power turbine. Francis turbines are the most commonly used hydro turbines. Ansyscfx was used to represent one vertical kaplan turbine unit by designing. Kaplan turbine is more compact in crosssection and has lower rotational speed to that of francis turbine. Kaplan turbine runner vanes are adjustable resistance to over come. Explain the significance of specific speed to turbine selection.
Its similar to the propeller turbine, except that its blades are adjustable. Comprehensive design of kaplan turbine runners for uprating this paper presents an application of the latest knowledge in hydraulic and mechanical design of the kaplan turbine runners for uprating projects. What is the difference between kaplan and francis turbines. Both turbines produced power due to both kinetic energy and pressure energy. Velocity of water at outlet of runner is very high 315% of net working head, for high specific speed it is 45% in case of kaplan turbine, by employing draft tube recovers this wasted ke is utilized which increases efficiency of the turbine.
Hydraulic turbines and hydroelectric power plants 1. The kaplan turbine was an evolution of the francis turbine. Francis and kaplan turbines notes for civil engineering. This is how we resolve our differences and can work our way out of this kind of situation. Jul 23, 20 what is the differences between pelton turbine and kaplan turbine. Francis turbine, kaplan and propeller turbine, deriaz turbine, tubuler turbine, fourneyron etc. The kaplan turbine is an axial flow reaction turbine, which means that the working fluid changes pressure as it moves through the turbine and gives up its energy.
As discussed above, it is a type of reaction turbine. In 19 kaplan designed a propeller turbine, named kaplan turbine. The runner of the this turbine has a large boss on which its blades are attached and the the blades of the runner is adjustable to an optimum angle of attack for maximum power output. In kaplan turbine, the number of blades in the runner is generally between 3 and 8. Kaplan turbine its components, working and application. This operates in an entirely closed conduit to tailrace. Load rejection transient process simulation of a kaplan turbine. The difference between the propeller and kaplan turbines is that the propeller turbine has fixed runner blades while the kaplan turbine has adjustable runner blades. Efficiency of kaplan turbine is higher than francis turbine. What is the difference between radial francis and mixed flow francis turbine. The primary difference between the two is that the runner blades in a propeller turbine are fixed while the runner blades of a kaplan turbine have an adjustable.
Propeller turbine vs kaplan turbine turbine machines. Francis turbines are generally arranged so that the axis is vertical. In francis turbine, the number of blades in the runner is generally between 16 and 24. Both serve almost the same purpose only names along with slight operating ways and their time of arrival is different. Differences between francis and kaplan turbines mech4study. Generally, double regulators are provided in a kaplan turbine. The head h is difference between headwater and tailwater. Difference between francis and kaplan turbine pdf 23. Jul 24, 20 working of francis turbine is explained in this video in a step by step logical manner, with help of animation.
A kaplan turbine has adjustments in both guide vanes and runner vanes. Load variation effects on the pressure fluctuations. Difference is on different point like direction of flow of water, number of runner, flow resistance of water, head of. Design consideration of basic parameters for 10kw kaplan turbine b. Gap between hub and ring and the runner blades gap between the blade and hub gap between the blade and ring spalteapning x sd vi r k ningsg r a d 0 0. Kaplan turbine francis turbine 1 water enters the runner vanes axially and leaves axially, hence it is called axial flow turbine. Design and analysis of a kaplan turbine runner wheel. Design and vibration characteristic analysis of 10kw kaplan. Pelton wheel is an impulse turbine where static pressure head of water is converted into mechanical energy. Pumped storage allow ready adjustment of the runnerblade angles to match the opposite requirements of pumping and power generation. Application of variable speed operation on francis turbines. Difference between kaplan and francis turbine youtube. Kaplan turbines could technically work across a wide range of heads and flow rates, but because of other turbine types being more effective on higher heads, and because kaplans are relative expensive, they are the turbine of choice for lower head sites with high flow rates.
Difference between frances turbine and kaplan turbine. B francis an american engineer who in beginning designed inward radial flow reaction turbine. Pdf modelling of the francis turbine runner in power. Application of variable speed operation on francis. The invention of kaplan turbine is evolution in the field of hydraulic turbines or we can say that it is the upgrade version of francis turbine. General arrangement of kaplan 1 introduction this short note indicates how a preliminary design of an axail. Kaplan turbines can operate under a wide range of head conditions. Kaplan turbine is a low headturbine and used for heads ofless than 80 meters. Difference between pelton, francis and kaplan turbines the pelton, francis and kaplan turbines are water turbines that are rotary machines which convert kinetic energy and the potential energy of the water into mechanical energy that rotates the shaft to produce electric energy. It is more compact in construction and smaller in size for the same power developed.
What is the difference between a pelton wheel and the. Oct 30, 2016 on this channel you can get education and knowledge for general issues and topics. The two main types of reaction turbine are the propeller turbine with kaplan variant and the francis turbine. This gallery from october 2009 is an alltime reader. The runner blades in the kaplan turbine is less in number.
Such a turbine was first designed by an austrian engineer, viktor kaplan and is therefore named after him as kaplan turbine. Difference between kaplan and francis turbine kaplan and francis are two types of turbines which were developed by two different engineers. Pdf application of variable speed operation on francis turbines. On the other hand, impulse turbine is pelton wheel, banki turbine. In impulse turbine all hydraulic energy is converted into kinetic energy by a nozzle and it is is the jet so produced which strikes the runner blades. The wheel is immersed and operates both the water velocity kinetic energy, that a pressure difference. It is an inwardflow reaction turbine that combines radial and axial flow concepts francis turbines are the most common water turbine in use today.
On the other hand francis and kaplan turbines are reaction turbine where dynamic pressure head of water is converted into mechanical energy. They operate in a water head from 40 to 600 m to 2,000 ft and are used primarily for electrical power production. In 1870 professor fink introduced an important improvement in francis. Difference between francis and kaplan turbines answers. A francis turbine is a reactiontype turbine having a runner with a large number of fixed buckets, usually nine or more, to which the water is supplied in a whirling radial direction. Design and vibration characteristic analysis of 10kw kaplan turbine runner blade profile international journal of scientific engineering and technology research volume. It was named after james bicheno francis 18151892, the american engineer who invented the apparatus in 1849. Engineer, viktor kaplan and is therefore named after him as kaplan turbine.
The main differences between impulse and reaction turbines are, all hydraulic energy is converted into kinetic energy by a nozzle in the impulse turbine and whereas in reaction turbine only some amount of the available energy is converted into kinetic energy. Francis, propeller and kaplan are the some commonly used reaction turbines. The difference in the operating head can be extra simply controlled in francis turbine than in the pelton wheel turbine. In kaplan turbine, the water flow is axia and in francis trubine it is radial.
Pdf influence of runner clearance on efficiency and cavitation in. Yaw osei adutwum has hinted of governments intention to borrow against their own promise during the 2016 campaign to complete all educational sector infrastructure projects at 70% of completion. Note that this analysis is approximate and is useful for a. What is the differences between pelton turbine and kaplan. The pelton, francis and kaplan turbines are water turbines that are rotary machines which convert. In kaplan turbine, the water flows axially in and axially out while in francis turbine it is radially in and axially out. Evolution from francis turbine to kaplan turbine wikipedia. It is an inwardflow reaction turbine that combines radial and axial flow concepts. Blade channel vortices in a francis turbine runner engineering computations volume. Guide on how to develop a small hydropower plant esha 2004 photo 6.
This difference in pressure is the reason of flowing of liquids i. Kaplan turbine it is an axial flow reaction turbine. Kaplan turbine the kaplan turbine is a greatdevelopment of early 19thcentury. Hi all in this video lecture i have discussed about the difference between francis turbine vs kaplan turbine from the unit turbine of fluid mechanics or fluid machineryhydraulics or hydraulics machinery. The turbine efficiency curve calculation is based on rated head design gross head less. Francis turbine variation in the operating head can be more simply controlled. The francis turbine was invented by james bicheno francis, a pioneer in early waterpower. The kaplan turbine runner has 38 blades while francis turbine runner has 1525 blades in general. Design of the runner of a kaplan turbine for small. Difference between propeller turbine and kaplan turbine with reference to their runner blades. The approximate ranges of head, flow and power applicable to the different turbine types are summarised in the chart of figure 1 up to 500kw power. Cfdbased design of a hydro turbine runner depending upon the parametrical and theoretical calculations to prevent cavitation and to increase the turbine efficiency.
Ageing due to startstop cycles and frequent regulation in. Kaplan versus francis turbine the advantages of kaplan. It consists of spiral casing, guide mechanism and draft tube of kaplan turbine runner are similar to those of francis turbine. The blade angle at the entrance is o 90 and the guide vane angle is o 15.
Overview of a typical powerhouse the powerhouse can also be at the base of an existing dam, where the water arrives via an existing. It has fixed runner blades and adjustable guide vanes. Hydraulic turbineshydraulic turbines raven mechanical. The kaplan turbine runner was modelled in 3d model of runner of kaplan turbine in proe engineer software and after calculating the blade. Before talking about the differences lets see some similarities 1. Modelling of the francis turbine runner in power stations. Kaplan turbine is employed, where a large quantity of water is available. May 06, 2017 hi all in this video lecture i have discussed about the difference between francis turbine vs kaplan turbine from the unit turbine of fluid mechanics or fluid machineryhydraulics or hydraulics machinery. The inward flow reaction turbine having radial discharge at outlet is known as francis turbine, after the name of j. The main focus is not only on the increase of efficiency and annual electricity production, but also on the extension of lifetime. The reverse archimedes screw and the overshot waterwheel are both gravity turbines. Francis turbine had some limitations which were overcome by kaplan turbine. Turbine selection criteria for small hydropower development. Hydraulic turbines fundamental operating parameters classification impulse turbines pelton turbines reaction turbines radial flow.
First, a theoretical design was performed for determining the main characteristics where it showed an efficiency of 94%. Jan 01, 2020 francis and kaplan turbines francis turbine. For a given head and output kaplan turbine runs at a higher speed. The difference between the pressures of runner is known as reaction pressure and these types of turbines are known as reaction turbine. Francis turbines are the most common water turbine in use today. For one type of francis turbine runner, all the parameters and their effects are illustrated with the help of cfd, considering the influence of. This turbine has a small number of blades generally 4. Expected statistical lifetimes of kaplan runners 34 kaplan runners manufactured 1936 to 1955 two manufacturers, similar design, 7 mw to 33 mw, head 6. What is the differences between pelton turbine and kaplan turbine.
In reaction turbine only some amount of the available energy is converted into kinetic energy before the fluid enters the runner. Explain the general principles of pelton wheels kaplan turbines francis turbine construct blade vector diagrams for moving vanes for a pelton wheels and a francis turbine deduce formulae for power and efficiency for turbines. The runner is completely enclosed that is it is air tight. Francis turbine requires relatively higher head conditions. In the kaplan turbine, the match relationship between the blade and. The governor regulates the guide blade opening as well as the runner vane angles simultaneously. The efficiency of a turbine is highly influenced by its runner wheel and this work aims to study the design of a kaplan turbine runner wheel. Difference between kaplan and francis turbine compare the. The type of turbine is entered by the user based on its suitability to the available head and flow conditions. Specificspeed application according to the approximation for past data 1, the relationship between the ratio of runner outlet diameter of a normal francis turbine d2 and runnerblade inlet diameter d1 and specific speed ns is plotted in fig. Kaplan turbine, runner pressure measurement, load variations. On this channel you can get education and knowledge for general issues and topics.
Like kaplan turbine, the francis is a reaction machine. It can be designed for operating heads ranging from 50 to 2,000 feet. Learn about the comparison between francis and kaplan turbines. Pelton turbine was developed by lester allan pelton in the year 1870. The pumping load can also be varied with deriaztype units, which cannot be done with a francis runner. Pdf effects of load variation on a kaplan turbine runner. Difference between impulse and reaction turbine with pdf. Following are the differences between pelton wheel, francis and kaplan turbine. The adjustment of guide vanes is similar to that of a francis turbine. The blades of the kaplan turbine has twist along its length. Kaplan versus francis turbine the advantages of kaplan over. Water enters the runner vanes radially and leaves axially, hence it is called a mixed flow turbine. Difference between frances turbine and kaplan turbine type of turbine.
The difference in the cam curves between the two methods was smaller than the estimated. Mar 24, 2014 difference between frances turbine and kaplan turbine type of turbine. Comparison between francis and kaplan turbines fluid. Comparison between impulse turbine and reaction turbine. Loss of energy due to friction of the blades is less due to the small number of blades. Apr 08, 2015 water is directed tangentially through the wicket gate and spirals on to a propeller shaped runner, causing it to spin. The head ranges from 1070 metres and the output ranges from 5 to 200 mw. Francis in 1849 developed the radial turbine, named francis turbine. Difference between kaplan and francis turbine compare.
Modelling and analysis of a very low head kaplan turbine. Difference between kaplan turbine and francis turbine. Propeller turbine vs kaplan turbine free download as powerpoint presentation. Very simple kaplan turbine design durham university. The kaplan is of the propellertype, similar to an airplanepropeller.
In kaplan turbine water enters axially and leaves axially, while in francis turbine water enters the runner radially and exits axially. The francis turbine is a type of water turbine that was developed by james b. Regulation of flow in reaction turbine is carried out by means of a guidevalve, scroll casing, stay ring runner. Increase area of water exit, increase whirling action, suit for. Efficiency of kaplan hydro power turbine is higher. The advantages of kaplan over francis are listed below. Water turbines are the modern successors of simple waterwheels, which date back about 2,000 years. General differences between francis and kaplan turbines. The runner blades in the kaplan turbine are less in number as the blades are twisted and covers a larger circumference. The first paper results showed that the torque starts to oscillate with the start of. Marine engineering mechanical engineering marine diesel engine motor diesel combustion engine heavy machinery industrial machinery world images heavy equipment. According to their construction, working and operating conditions following are the major.
8 201 88 1182 844 1484 342 263 1235 771 903 479 264 1302 990 1280 1568 162 83 422 998 423 217 377 879 801 983 1527 1009 15 1429 825 69 1473 425 1326 144 1137 441 1488 612 864 9